2008 Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution MR

Months in Fleet: 10
Mileage to Date: 25,000

Our affair with a 2008 Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution continues to run the gamut. One staffer piles on praise for the handling and suspension tuning, then another comes along and complains the car feels like it's falling apart and costs far too much. Though cars like an Evo aren't supposed to be for everyone, the range of comments it elicits is pretty entertaining.

Here's Web producer Evan McCausland, who's spent a lot of time in the Evo and a few nights in our Four Seasons 2010 Nissan GT-R: "I know the Evo MR is still wicked fast and a blast to drive, but what used to feel like neck-snapping acceleration feels rather sedate, now that I've driven the GT-R (and, no, I didn't play with the GT-R's launch control)."

I, too, thought the Evo was starting to feel a bit pedestrian, until I looked at the speedometer and noticed I was going far too fast for a public road. I then scribbled the following in our logbook, "God help us if cars like the Evo start to feel sedate or mundane. Maybe we need to spend some time in a Chevy Aveo to recalibrate our sense of sedate."

Senior editor Joe Lorio explained the Evo best: "Many have complained about the Evo's humble, Lancer origins, but I think that's part of the charm of a car like this. The Evo, and its ilk, are the muscle cars of today. Like those '60s machines based on bare-bones Tempests, Belvederes, and Chevelles, this Mitsubishi spends ALL its money and effort on performance, and nothing, really, on comfort, convenience, or even styling." That formula works for Lorio, but he acknowledges that not everyone will feel the same way: "Will most people prefer a BMW 335i? Absolutely. But I wouldn't want the Evo to become one."

New associate editor Eric Tingwall spent a few nights in the Evo, a car he hadn't driven since he was an intern with us last summer, and he quickly remembered how the tricky throttle/clutch interaction dampens low-speed maneuvers: "It's especially bad when backing out of a parking space. I'd find myself jumping into the car, throwing it into reverse and then nervously feathering the throttle, as it took me forever to back out."

We just dropped the Evo at the dealer awaiting new transmission fluid to see if that improves the response from the transmission while accelerating from a stop. The dealer needed to order transmission fluid. A service rep also questioned our choice to swap the fluid before the 30,000-mile interval specified in the owner's manual, but we assured him the 25,000 miles we have accumulated were anything but easy on the car and fluid. We will know soon whether the fluid makes as big a difference as we've been told to expect.